Review
“In a brilliant riposte to scholarly conventions, and one that many scholars might want to qualify, Mr. Mancall . . . reconstructs an early colonial experience that is troubled and contested, one that provides a powerful counter-narrative to the traditional accounts that have been institutionalized as clichés in the Thanksgiving tradition.”—Crawford Gribben, Wall Street Journal
“With verve, tact, and insight, Mancall has teased out those strands of Morton’s career that suggest an attractive alternative to some of the grim realities of early American history. As the most recent witness in Morton’s ongoing ‘trial,’ he has launched a vigorous, though not impartial, defense of a complicated man.”—Christopher Benfey, New York Review of Books
“Historian Peter Mancall deconstructs the traditional narrative that traces the origins of the American nation to Puritan colonization. . . . This book offers a nuanced contribution to historiographical as well as public debates.”—La Vie des Idées
“Mancall’s book is lively, fascinating, and highly readable. . . . Mancall has meticulously reconstructed a neglected episode in colonial history and the twists and turns of the publishing, reception, and subsequent use of a mischievous book.”—Orthodox Presbyterian Church
“Mancall’s book is lively, fascinating, and highly readable.”—Ordained Servant
“Mancall . . . offer[s] rich historical and historiographical detail and considerable food for thought. . . . Morton was clearly having a great deal of fun, but Mancall reminds us that he was also engaged in deadly serious political theater aimed at undermining the legal standing of the Puritan settlements.”—Reviews in American History
“[A] telling alternative to the familiar story of New England, a corrective to a history that became so dominant as to eclipse other real possibilities for settlement.”—Kathleen Donegan, William and Mary Quarterly
“Engagingly written, insightfully argued, and offer(s) fascinating, sometimes rollicking, tours through the ways Puritans have been characterized—and caricatured—over time.”—Jenny Hale Pulsipher, Reviews in American History
“Mancall’s lovely little book may . . . open Morton’s world and ideas to a new generation of Americans.”—Daniel Mandell, Journal of American History
“From start to finish, The Trials of Thomas Morton offers fresh approaches to reframing the well-told tale of life in seventeenth-century New England. . . . Mancall’s comprehensive book-length study is long overdue.”—Charlotte Carrington-Farmer, New England Quarterly
“Compelling. . . . A page-turner of the best kind.”—Matt Cohen, Early American Literature
“Thomas Morton is one of the great anti-heroes in American history. Attorney, trader, Puritan critic, Native American admirer, Morton at last has the biography his picaresque life deserves. Peter Mancall’s deeply researched and beautifully written book brings Morton to life and promises to change the way we think about early America.”—Louis P. Masur, Rutgers University
“In this absorbing work, Peter C. Mancall rescues Thomas Morton from the realms of fiction and wishful thinking he has long inhabited. By exploring Morton’s alternative vision for English colonization, Mancall poignantly reminds us of roads not taken.”—Alison Games, author of The Web of Empire: English Cosmopolitans in an Age of Expansion, 1560–1660
“By focusing his narrative on Morton Mancall introduces contingency into early New England history, showing that alternatives were possible—if only they had been pursued.”—Mary Beth Norton, author of In the Devil’s Snare: The Salem Witchcraft Crisis of 1692
“The Trials of Thomas Morton uses the life of the ‘Lord of Misrule,’ who enraged Puritans by dancing with Indians around a Maypole, and a study of Morton’s strange New English Canaan (1637), to offer a startling counter-narrative of early New England history.”—Christopher Grasso, author of Skepticism and American Faith: From the Revolution to the Civil War
About the Author
Peter C. Mancall, the Andrew W. Mellon Professor of the Humanities and professor of history and anthropology at the University of Southern California, is the author of six books about early America.
